Wednesday, February 7, 2007

Nanny

Janie's grandmother, Nanny, plays a small, but important role in Janie's story. She wants a good life for Janie, but at the same time encourages Janie to enter into a loveless marriage. What do you think has influenced Nanny to do this? Do you think she is right to do so, or wrong?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

I believe Nanny has played a huge role in Janie's life, despite the fact that she isn't mentioned very much throughout the novel. Nanny wants a better life for Janie, anything other than what Nanny went through as a kid/young adult. Nanny wants to see Janie be with a man who will take care of her and protect her. Something Nanny didn't have at all as she was growing up. I believe thats the reason why Nanny had so much influence in Janie's life, she just wanted to see Janie have a happy life.
I think it was right for Nanny to care about Janie's up-bringing so much, but I think it would've been a beeter idea if Nanny didn't control it as much as she did. It would've been better to have Janie have some input about her future, therefore she would be happier.

Anonymous said...

We see this same desire today in parents who pressure their children to pursue only those fields that will be lucrative (esp. medicine), whether or not the child's inclinations or talents like in that direction. All the focus is on getting a good-paying job. Nothing whatever has changed and the results (the child having to struggle for years to discover who s/he really is) are also the same.

Anonymous said...

After reading the book i realize why Nanny wanted her granddaughter to enter an arranged and loveless marriage. She did it as a form of protection. Nanny believed that the absence of love in the relationship would protect Janie from getting hurt. Janie married Logan Killicks and was determined to find love in the relationship, but that failed. She did not want to be safe from being hurt if it meant living with a man she did not love. Nanny tried hard to save Janie, but Janie did not want to be saved.

Anonymous said...

I think the fact that Nanny was a slave and had a child by her white master (probably through rape) and that Janie's mother was raped by her teacher had a lot to do with Nanny's wish for Janie to marry, even without love. She would rather have a secure relationship for Janie than allow for the possibility of her having a child out of wedlock.