Tuesday, February 20, 2007
Doubts
Despite Janie’s growing love for Tea Cake, she still has doubts about it. In Chapter 13 she has discovered that her $200 is missing and Tea Cake has been gone all day. She begins to worry and is reminded of a story about Annie Taylor (page 118-119). Do you think that her fears and worries are natural? Do you, as a reader, trust Tea Cake at this point in the story or do you still have doubts about him? Why or why not?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
At this point of time, I think that Janie's fears are only too natural because she has yet to find out a lot of Tea Cake. Infact at this point, Janie doesn't know TeaCake really well, this with the story of Annie Taylor should have given Janie doubts, so her fears are only too natural.
At this point of time as a reader, I don't completely trust TeaCake since he could be after her money. He could simply take her money and leave her as what happened to Annie Taylor.
However, when he tells Janie to keep her money in the bank and when he tells her that he will provide for all, then I'm inclined to believe that TeaCake loves Janie.
When Janie realizes her money is gone she has reason to be worried. She isn't in an unfamilar place with a man she doesn't know all that well. She took a big leap by going with Tea Cake and fortunatly she lands safely.
There isn't a reason to trust Tea Cake at this point. He appears as a man wanting to take advantage of Janie's new situation. He also spends an extravagent amount of money on a party he doesn't take Janie to.
Tea Cake redeems himself when he succeeds in gambling back the money and not taking further advantage of Janie.
Janie has every right to be nervous about the situation. There is just to great a risk of him cheating her for her to stay calm. The fact that she knows of someone who had it happened to them just makes the problem all the more real. Tea Cake is too new of a character, to me, for him to be trusted with such a large amount of money.
Janie's fears and worries are completely natural. She only recently married and moved in with Tea Cake. Thus, there could be another side to Tea Cake that he managed to hide for the time he was around Janie. So, Janie's actions fit perfectly with the situation. Personly, I don't fully trust Tea Cake. He seems nice, but Janie does not seem to spend enough time around him to just move and marry him. Somebody in Tea Cake's position would surely try to hide their faults or true intentions of they were poor and she was rich. There for, Tea Cake has not proven his-self yet in the story.
Janie begins to worry after Tea Cake takes 200 dollars and messes with it like its nothing. Her fears and worries are natural. If your companion was to steal 200 dollars and blow it off on something stupid how would that make you feel. As a reader, I have my doubts about Tea cake and his issues, but he showed he truly loved Janie when he came back and apologized and said he would make up that money he lost. I still believe that he is in it for Janie and not the money
Chris Lyons is the cooliest person in the world
Janie should be nervous and should have doubts as to whether Tea Cake is trustworthy or not. She has heard people criticize him before, so she probably is not confident that he will return with the money. She knows nothing about the town they are in, so she is virtually helpless. The "Annie Tyler" story has to be on Janie's mind in this situation. Janie is out on a limb, and Tea Cake could cut the limb off at any time.
I think that Janie is right in questioning Teacake and his motifs. I feel like she doesn't know Teacake very well. If I woke up and my $200 was gone i would start panicing and be afraid as well. I think it was normal for Janie to automatically think back to Annie Taylor's story because their stories seem similar. At this point I don't trust Teacake. I don't like how he can sweet talk his way out of any trouble he has with Janie. I think Teacake is too spontaneous
Post a Comment