Thursday, February 1, 2007
Criticism and Controversy
While Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God is considered today as one of the most important African American novels, it was not as well received when it was first published in 1937. Particularly, it received much criticism from other authors and artists involved in the Harlem Renaissance. Richard Wright, the author of Native Son wrote of the book, “The sensory sweep of her novel carries no theme, no message, no thought.” Why do you think the book created such controversy? If it had been written today, how do you think it would have been different?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Richard Wright's wording of "sensory sweep" describes the novel quite well. But that’s where my agreement of his criticism ends.
Hurston's poetic language simply captivated me as a reader. It was so intimate that I felt as if I were Phoeby, hearing Janie's story firsthand. At any moment, I might reach out and touch her shoulder.
Today, I think her story stands strong against novels by modern American female authors. Janie outlines the drama of her life not in three acts, but in three marriages. Love, death and divorce are still strong themes in today’s great fiction by women. Hurston could easily sit at the dining room table beside Toni Morrison, Alice Hoffman, Kaye Gibbons, Alice Walker, Ellen Gilchrist and Amy Tan. What an interesting meal they might share.
When "Their Eyes Were Watching God" was writen the african americans were just starting to come out of their former depression under the whites. This book showed African Americans as people, good and bad. the Renaissance wanted all of the images of black people to be good. They thought that the gave them some bad images so they ripped on it.
If the book was writen today, the out come would have been totally different. People wouldnt see it as the journey of an original African American. They would have seen it as some one trying to portray the original African American.
Post a Comment